Personal Grading on a cartoon show

  • We have upgraded to Xenforo 2. We've decided to open the forums back up while we configure the theme and plugins. Thanks for your patience.

Latest News

NeoplanDan

Avid SEPTA Transit Fan
Apr 24, 2016
2,482
Ratings
1,402 9
113
Philadelphia PA
cricketgreens.tumblr.com
#1
Well this is the first time that I post a topic, to start off, the topic is how do you personally grade a show that you watch, whether it's from Cartoon Network, Nickelodeon, Disney, etc, choose which on ones that has it higher or lower.

Please note that this just a grading topic, and hate comments on a show is not tolerated here because this will start arguments and we don't need to make anyone from either side upset or angered, even though the level of the grading varies on how the person feels about it.

Start Posting.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Sep 25, 2011
327
Ratings
9
18
Oakley California
#2
CARTOON NETWORK:
A+: Steven Universe
A+: Adventure Time
B: We Bare Bears
C+: Clarence
D (Formerly C-): Uncle Grandpa
F: The Powerpuff Girls (2016)
NICKELODEON/NICK JR.
NICK:
A+: The Loud House
B-: Bunsen is a Beast
C: SpongeBob SquarePants
NICK JR.:
B (Formerly A+): Shimmer and Shine
DISNEY CHANNEL/XD/JUNIOR:
DC:
A+ Tsum Tsum Shorts
B+: Mickey Mouse shorts
B-: Elena of Avalor
DXD:
A+: Star vs the Forces of Evil
B: Milo Murphy's Law
JUNIOR:
A+: Sofia the First
A+: Kate and Mim Mim
B: P. King Duckling
 

I.R. Shokew

DISGRACED and Rooting ONLY for Underdogs
Sep 26, 2011
9,919
Ratings
1,741 8
113
Who wants to find me that badly anymore?
#3
UGH...

Nickelodeon:
Harvey Beaks = A
The Loud House = B

Sanjay & Craig = C (F for the gross-out humor based efforts that plagued the show early on and did it no favors.)
Everything else = WHO CARES???

CN:
Amazing World of Gumball = A

Clarence = B+ (I'd give it an A- if it weren't for certain characters dragging things down for me - e.g.: Belson, Jeff.)
Adventure Time = B+ (Would have been A- if not for how Finn's character gets messed with due to romantic nonsense.)
Regular Show = B+ (Would have been A if not for the romantic nonsense that shows up at certain points)
We Bare Bears = B
Mighty Magiswords = B (Can become a solid A if the pacing improves.)
Steven Universe = C+ (Would have been A- if not for the boring comedy and lethargic pacing to get to the good stuff...)

Everything else = WHO CARES???

DC/DXD:
Milo Murphy's Law = A- (so far, so good.)
Star Wars Rebels = A-

Gravity Falls = B (Season 1 is a C, Season 2 is a solid A)
Penn Zero: Part Time Hero = B (hopefully, Season 2 will boost this to a B+; I'm not counting on an A.)
Future-Worm = B- (Just, good stupid fun for me.)
Pickle and Peanut = B- (Same as Future-Worm when it hits for me.)
Star Vs. The Forces of Evil = C+ (Decent enough lore and animation/art-style, however - doesn't truly interest me like I thought it first would, hence my anger at it.)
Wander Over Yonder = C
The 7D = C
Everything else = WHO CARES???

Acquisitions:
Atomic Puppet = B+ (It needs a 2nd season to get hopefully even better.)
Fangbone! = B+ (Same as Atomic Puppet.)
The ZhuZhus = B+ (Littlest Pet Shop (2012) done in a much better way.)
 
Last edited:

NeoplanDan

Avid SEPTA Transit Fan
Apr 24, 2016
2,482
Ratings
1,402 9
113
Philadelphia PA
cricketgreens.tumblr.com
#4
To Me, personally

Cartoon Network
We Bare Bears: A (92)
Steven Universe: (91)
Clarence: B (87)
Gumball: B (86)
Adventure Time: B (85)
Mighty Magisword: C (70)
Uncle Grandpa D (69)
PPG 2016: D (64)

Nickelodeon
The Loud House: A (99)
Harvey Beaks: A (90)
Bunsen is a Beast: B (82)

Disney XD
Milo Murphy's Law: A (98)
Star Vs the Forces of Evil: A (91)
Penn Zero: B (89)
Right Now Kapow: B (81)
Future-Worm: C (79)

Others
Atomic Puppet: A (99)
Danger Mouse: A (96)
Fangbone: A (90)
Counterfeit Cat: B (81)
Supernoobs: C (76)
My Knight and Me: C (71)
CWACO: D (68)

-The only reason why i'd never added Regular Show, Wander Over Yonder, and The 7D, it's because i can only count the ones that are currently airing/shows that had not ended yet.
Got no more to add

THAT'S ALL, FOLKS
 
Last edited:

Cartoon Ruler

Senior Member
Dec 11, 2011
4,243
Ratings
1,902 7
113
Galloway, NJ
#5
I've already rated the current Disney cartoons, now I'm grading them this time.

Disney XD
Pickle and Peanut - B
Star vs. the Forces of Evil - B+
Counterfeit Cat - B+
Milo Murphy's Law - A-
Future-Worm! - B
Atomic Puppet - A-
Penn Zero: Part-Time Hero - A-
Star Wars Rebels - A-
Right Now Kapow! - C+
Fangbone! - A-
Two More Eggs - D-

Disney Channel
The ZhuZhus - B-
Mickey Mouse - B+

Nickelodeon
SpongeBob SquarePants - A- (Seasons 1-3), C (Season 4-5), D- (Seasons 6-8), B+ (Seasons 9-)
The Loud House - B+ (pretty good cartoon, but it definitely has its flaws)
Harvey Beaks - A (has been staying constantly great so far)
Pig Goat Banana Cricket - D
Bunsen is a Beast! - C+
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - B-
Rabbids Invasion - C-
Get Blake! - C (it's Kid vs. Kat done a bit better)
The Fairly OddParents - B (Seasons 1-3), C+ (Seasons 4-8), D (Seasons 9-10)

Cartoon Network
Adventure Time - B
Steven Universe - A-
We Bare Bears - B+
Clarence - B
The Amazing World of Gumball - A-
Mighty Magiswords - B (if there was less pacing, it would've been an B+)
Teen Titans Go! - D (it can have a good episode once in a while, otherwise there's nothing good I can say for this show)
The Powerpuff Girls - C- (a slightly better reboot than TTG, but it ain't that good)
Uncle Grandpa - C- (it's better than Secret Mountain Fort Awesome, but still nothing special)
Supernoobs - D+ (it's more tolerable than Johnny Test, but it's still lame)
My Knight and Me - C
Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs - D+

Boomerang
Be Cool, Scooby-Doo! - B
Bunnicula - B+
Peanuts - A
Shaun the Sheep - A-
Wabbit - B
The Tom and Jerry Show - B+

Discovery Family
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic - C (I'm aware that everyone calls it a great cartoon, but I'm just not really into it)

FOX
Bob's Burgers - B+
Family Guy - C+ (Seasons 1-6), F (Seasons 7-)
The Simpsons - A- (Seasons 1-8), B- (Seasons 9-20), C+ (Seasons 20-)
 
Last edited:

Spacething7474

Click the image to change your avatar.
May 21, 2017
282
Ratings
418
43
14
Minnesota. Just Minnesota.
#6
Here's for me. A=Great. B=Good. C=Okay. D=Bad. F=Awful. {Nickelodeon/Nicktoons:}
  • (Bunsen Is A Beast!,B)
  • (Get Blake!,B+)
  • (ALVINNN!!! And The Chipmunks,B)
  • (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2012,C+)
  • (The Fairly OddParents [seasons 1-2,D-] [seasons 3-5,C+] [seasons 6-10,A])
  • (SpongeBob SquarePants,A)
  • (The Loud House,D-)
  • (Kid Danger,A)
  • (Harvey Beaks,B)
  • (Pig Goat Banana Cricket,A-)
  • (Sanjay And Craig,A)
  • (Breadwinners,A)
  • (Fanboy and Chum Chum,A)
  • (Planet Sheen,A)
  • (T.U.F.F Puppy,A-)
  • (The Legend Of Korra,C-)
  • (Rabbids Invasion,A)
  • (Kuu Kuu Harajuku,F)
  • (Wild Grinders,A)
  • (Regal Academy,D-)
  • (Winx Club,F)
  • (Rocket Monkeys,B+)
  • (Mysticons,D-)
  • (Welcome To The Wayne,C)
  • (Back At The Barnyard,A)
  • (The Mighty B!,C+)
{Cartoon Network/Boomerang:}
  • (Teen Titans Go!,A-)
  • (Uncle Grandpa,A)
  • (Clarence,B)
  • (Wabbit,B-)
  • (Be Cool Scooby-Doo!,A)
  • (Mixels,A)
  • (My Knight And Me,B-)
  • (Cloudy With A Chance Of Meatballs: The Series,B)
  • (Adventure Time,B-)
  • (Craig Of The Creek,C)
  • (Apple And Onion,A)
  • (Summer Camp Island, D+)
  • (The Amazing World Of Gumball,C+)
  • (Mighty Magiswords,B+)
  • (Total Drama,F)
  • (Peanuts 2016,C+)
  • (Sym Bionic Titan,C-)
  • (Regular Show,B-)
  • (O.K K.O! Let's Be Heroes!,F)
  • (MAD: TAS,B)
  • (Robotomy,B+)
  • (The Powerpuff Girls 2016,F)
  • (Johnny Test,A)
  • (Bunnicula,B)
  • (Sonic Boom,A)
  • (Secret Mountain Fort Awesome,B+)
  • (Supernoobs,A-)
  • (The Tom And Jerry Show 2014,C)
  • (We Bare Bears,C+)
  • (Shaun The Sheep,A)
  • (Ben 10 2016,B)———————————————————————-———- {Disney Channel/Disney XD:}—————————————————————————
  • (Billy Dilley,B+)
  • (Right Now Kapow!,A)
  • (Star Vs. The Forces Of Evil,D+)
  • Future-Worm!,A)
  • (Pickle and Peanut,A)
  • (Star Wars Rebels,B+)
  • (Wander Over Yonder,B)
  • (The ZhuZhus,B)
  • (Gravity Falls,C+)
  • (Phineas and Ferb,A)
  • (Mickey Mouse 2013,C+)
  • (Tangled: The Series,C-)
  • (Elena of Avalor,C+)
  • (Penn Zero: Part-Time Hero,B)
  • (Milo Murphy's Law,A-)
  • (Lego Star Wars,A)
  • (Hotel Transylvania: The Series,D)
  • (Counterfeit Cat,F)
  • (Atomic Puppet,B)
  • (Fangbone!,B) And that's how I would grade the shows.
 
Last edited:

Mikurotoro92

Well-Known Member
Jun 17, 2015
1,672
Ratings
484 5
48
#7
Ok I'll start with Disney Junior:

Disney Junior:

P. King Duckling (F)
Goldie & Bear (F)
Mickey and the Roadster Racers (A)
Sofia the First (A)
Elena of Avalor (A)
Doc McStuffins (A)
Puppy Dog Pals (F)
Miles from Tomorrowland (A)
The Lion Guard (A)
Octonauts (A)

Disney Channel:

Tangled the Series (C)
The ZhuZhus (F)
Mickey Mouse *shorts* (C)
Tsum Tsum *shorts* (A)
Lego Friends of Heartlake City (n/a)

Disney XD:

Billy Dilley's Super-Duper Subterranean Summer (F)
Milo Murphy's Law (C)
Star VS the Forces of Evil (C)
Star Wars Rebels (D)
Future-worm (n/a)
Penn Zero: Part-time Hero (D)
Lego Star Wars: the Freemaker Adventures (n/a)
Lego Star Wars: the Resistance *shorts* (n/a)
Marvel's Avengers: Secret Wars (n/a)
Marvel's Guardians of the Galaxy (n/a)
Marvel's Spider-Man (n/a)
Marvel's Spider-Man VS the Sinister 6 (n/a)
Marvel's Rocket & Groot *shorts* (n/a)
Pokémon the series: Sun & Moon (D)
Beyblade Burst (B)
Yo-Kai Watch (B)

Discovery Family:

My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic (F)
Transformers Prime (C)
Transformers Rescue Bots (F)
Blazing Team (C)
Littlest Pet Shop 2012 (F)
Strawberry Shortcake's Berry Bitty Adventures (F)

Sprout:

Caillou (C)
Floogals (C)
The Ollie & Moon Show (n/a)

Cartoon Network/Adult Swim:

Steven Universe (D)
Teen Titans Go (C)
Clarence (D)
Adventure Time (C)
Ben 10 2017 (D)
The Powerpuff Girls 2017 (D)
Uncle Grandpa (C)
The Amazing World of Gumball (C)
We Bare Bears (C)
Lego Ninjago: Masters of Spinjitsu (C)
Robot Chicken (C)
Rick and Morty (D)
Samurai Jack season 5 (C)
Dragon Ball Super (C)
Dragon Ball Kai: The Final Chapters (C)
Hunter x Hunter (C)
Naruto Shippuden (B)
Naruto uncut (B)
Tokyo Ghoul (B)
Attack on Titan (F)
Gundam Unicorn RE:0096 (C)
Ghost in the Shell: Standalone Complex (C-)

Boomerang:

Be Cool Scooby-doo (F)
Grizzy and the Lemmings (F)
Peanuts *shorts* (C)
Sonic Boom (D)

Nickelodeon:

The Loud House (C)
SpongeBob SquarePants (C, B, or A depending on the episode)
Bunsen is a Beast (F)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles 2012 (C+)
Alvinnn!!! and The Chipmunks (C)

Nicktoons:

Fairly Odd Parents (same as SpongeBob)
Harvey Beaks (C)
Yu-Gi-Oh Arc-5 (C)

Nick Jr:

Shimmer and Shine (F)
Kuu Kuu Harajuku (C)
Paw Patrol (B)
Nella the Princess Knight (n/a)
Dora and Friends into the City (F)
Bubble Guppies (F)
Blaze and the Monster Machines (C)
Rusty Rivets (C)
Little Charmers (D)

* n/a means I either have never seen or watched enough of the show to properly grade it

That's it for now!
 
Last edited:

ShadowBeast

Well-Known Member
May 9, 2013
5,758
Ratings
1,903 10
113
Elizabeth,NJ
#8
Cartoon Network
Steven Universe - A
Powerpuff Girls 2016 - C
Adventure Time - B-
Regular Show - B
Be Cool Sbooby Doo - F
Clarence - D-
Cloudy with A Chance of Meatball - F
Gumball - C+
Justice League Action - A
Mighty Magiswords - B-
Over the Garden Wall - A+
Supernoobs - C+
Teen Titans Go - F+ (the plus is for the very, very few good episodes)
Uncle Grandpa - C-
We Bare Bears - B

Disney
Gravity Falls - A+
Wander Over Yonder - A
Kick Buttowski - B+
Right Now KaPow - A
Pickle and Peanut - F
Star Vs - B-
Phineas and Ferb - A
Penn Zero - B
Milo Murphy's Law - A
Avengers: Earth's Mightest Heroes - A
Avengers Assemble - F-
Lego Star Wars Freemaker Adventure - B
Future Worm - C-

Discovery Family
My Little Pony Friendship is Magic (seperated by seasons)
seasons 1-4 - A+
seasons 5- 7 - B
Littlest Pet Shop - B

Nickelodeon
Fairly OddParents (seperated by seasons)
seasons 0-5 - A+
seasons 6-7 - B-
seasons 8-9 - D
season 10 - B
The Loud House - A
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - D (started off strong, but spiraled downhill)
Spongebob - C
Bunsen is a Beast - F-

Fox
The Simpsons - C
Family Guy - D-
American Dad - F (show got horrendous once Roger kept getting away with stuff)
Bob's Burgers - D-
The Cleveland Show - F-

I didn't rate shows I don't watch or know enough about.
 
Last edited:

NeoplanDan

Avid SEPTA Transit Fan
Apr 24, 2016
2,482
Ratings
1,402 9
113
Philadelphia PA
cricketgreens.tumblr.com
#9
To Me, personally

Cartoon Network
We Bare Bears: A (92)
Steven Universe: (91)
Clarence: B (87)
Gumball: B (86)
Adventure Time: B (85)
Mighty Magisword: C (70)
Uncle Grandpa D (69)
PPG 2016: D (64)

Nickelodeon
The Loud House: A (99)
Harvey Beaks: A (90)
Bunsen is a Beast: B (82)

Disney XD
Milo Murphy's Law: A (98)
Star Vs the Forces of Evil: A (91)
Penn Zero: B (89)
Right Now Kapow: B (81)
Future-Worm: C (79)

Others
Atomic Puppet: A (99)
Danger Mouse: A (96)
Fangbone: A (90)
Counterfeit Cat: B (81)
Supernoobs: C (76)
My Knight and Me: C (71)
CWACO: D (68)

-The only reason why i'd never added Regular Show, Wander Over Yonder, and The 7D, it's because i can only count the ones that are currently airing/shows that had not ended yet.
Got no more to add

THAT'S ALL, FOLKS
UPDATED
Cartoon Network
We Bare Bears: A- (93.9)
Steven Universe: A- (90)
Clarence: B (85)
Gumball: B- (84)
Adventure Time: B- (83)
Ben 10 (2016) C- (70)
Mighty Magisword: D+ (69)
Uncle Grandpa D (65)
PPG 2016: D (65)

Nickelodeon
The Loud House: A (99)
Harvey Beaks: B (85)
Bunsen is a Beast: C (70)

Disney XD
Milo Murphy's Law: A (97.5)
Star Vs the Forces of Evil: A (90)
Penn Zero: B (80)
Billy Dilley's Super-Duper Subterranean Summer C (75)
Right Now Kapow: C (71)
Future-Worm: D (69)

Others
Atomic Puppet: A (95)
Danger Mouse: A (95)
Fangbone: B (87)
Counterfeit Cat: C (79)
Supernoobs: C (71)
Toonmarty C (70)
My Knight and Me: D (67)
Chuck's Choice D (65)
CWACO: F (61)




Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

Action!

Active Member
Jan 23, 2016
785
Ratings
294 5
28
#10
Nickelodeon
SpongeBob SquarePants A+ (99)
The Loud House A (95)
Alvin and the Chipmunks! B (85)
Rise of the Teenage Mutant Turtles F (65)
The Adventures of Kid Danger F (65)
Pig, Goat, Banana, Cricket F (49)
Cartoon Network
Steven Universe A- (92)
Craig of the Creek B+ (88)
Adventure Time B+ (88)
We Bare Bears B (85)
Apple & Onion B (85)
Clarance B (85)
The Amazing World of Gumball B- (82)
Ben 10! C+ (75)
Teen Titans Go! F (38)
Disney Channel
Big City Green B (83)
Big Hero 6: The Series B (85)
Duck Tales C+ (78)
 
Last edited:

Golden Geek

Gera Gera Po
Dec 31, 2013
1,194
Ratings
527 11
63
United States
#11
Just working off what I remember. If it seems like I'm a Disney cartoon fanboy, I just don't remember/avoid shows I know I won't enjoy (like Star Wars Rebels since I don't enjoy Star Wars at all).

Cartoon Network:

Adventure Time: B
Almost Naked Animals: D
The Amazing World of Gumball: B+
Chowder: B
Clarence: C+
Dexter's Laboratory: B+
Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends: A-
Johnny Test: D+
The Looney Tunes Show: B
MAD: C
The Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack: B+
The Powerpuff Girls (original series): A-
The Powerpuff Girls (2016): D-
Regular Show: B+
Sidekick: C+
Steven Universe: B
Teen Titans: A-
Teen Titans Go!: F
ThunderCats (2011): B
Sym-Bionic Titan: A
Uncle Grandpa: F
We Bare Bears: A

Disney Channel/Disney XD:

The Emperor's New School: B-
Fish Hooks: B-
Gravity Falls: A
Kick Buttowski: Suburban Daredevil: C+
Kim Possible: A-
Lilo & Stitch: The Series: B
Phineas and Ferb: B
Pickle and Peanut: F
The Replacements: B+
Star vs. the Forces of Evil: B+
Wander Over Yonder: B
Yin Yang Yo!: B+

Nickelodeon:

All Grown Up!: C
Alvin and the Chipmunks: C
As Told by Ginger: B
Avatar: The Last Airbender: A
Breadwinners: D-
The Fairly OddParents: C+ (this started as an A, but the latest seasons have really hurt it)
Fanboy and Chum Chum: D+
Harvey Beaks: A
The Legend of Korra: B+
The Loud House: A-
Making Fiends: A
Miraculous Ladybug: B
Planet Sheen: F
Sanjay and Craig: C-
Pig Goat Banana Cricket: F
Rugrats: B (Pre-Dil Rugrats may be my favorite Nicktoon.)
SpongeBob SquarePants: B-
T.U.F.F. Puppy: C-

MTV:

Clone High: A
Daria: B+
Downtown: B+

PBS:

Arthur: B
The Berenstain Bears: B
Caillou: D
Fetch! with Ruff Ruffman: A
Redwall: A-
 

ShadowBeast

Well-Known Member
May 9, 2013
5,758
Ratings
1,903 10
113
Elizabeth,NJ
#12
Adding to my list thanks to Golden Geek for reminding me of shows I forgot to add the first time round.


Cartoon Network
Fosters Home for Imaginary Friends - B+
Johnny Test - F
Teen Titans (seperated by season)
seasons 1-4 - A+
season 5 - C (The season was weak compared to the previous seasons. And ending it with a Beast Boy episode instead of a team episode was just a bad way to end the series.)


Disney
Jimmy Two Shoes - A
Yin Yang Yo - C

Nickelodeon
TUFF Puppy - B-
All Grown Up - A
Sanjay and Craig - F
Planet Sheen - F
Avatar - A
Legend of Korra - C (even despite having some great characters, the whole show was a huge mess)
Fanboy and Chum Chum - F
 

AdrenalineRush1996

Well-Known Member
May 13, 2016
1,008
Ratings
481 2
63
21
#13
Here's mine and it doesn't include every show that I've seen.

Cartoon Network and Boomerang
*Ed, Edd n Eddy: A+
*Cow and Chicken: A
*Regular Show: A
*Adventure Time: A
*Ben 10: TOS: A
*Ben 10: Alien Force: A+
*Ben 10: Ultimate Alien: A
*Teen Titans: A
*Justice League: A+
*Xiaolin Showdown: A
*Chop Socky Chooks: B
*Robotboy: A
*My Gym Partner is a Monkey: C
*The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy: A
*Codename: Kids Next Door: A+
*The Powerpuff Girls 1998: A+
*Dexter's Laboratory (original era): A+
*Dexter's Laboratory (Savino era): B
*Courage the Cowardly Dog: A+
*Batman: The Brave and the Bold: A
*Shaggy and Scooby Get a Clue: D
*Teen Titans Go!: F
*Johnny Test: D
*Generator Rex: A
*Loonatics Unleashed: A
*The Batman: A
*ThunderCats 2011: A
*The Life and Times of Juniper Lee: A
*Samurai Jack: A
*Batman Beyond: A
*Angelo Rules: A
*Transformers: Prime (it aired on CN in the UK): A
*Ben 10: Omniverse: D
*Star Wars: The Clone Wars: A+

Nickelodeon and Nicktoons
*SpongeBob (season 1-4): A+
*Fairly Odd Parents (season 1-7): A+
*SpongeBob (season 5-present): D
*Fairly Odd Parents (season 8-present): D
*Danny Phantom: A
*Fanboy and Chum Chum: F
*Avatar: The Last Airbender: A+
*Avatar: The Legend of Korra: A
*Planet Sheen: C
*The Adventures of Jimmy Neutron: A
*Invader Zim: A
*Skyland: A
*Transformers Animated (it aired on Nicktoons in the UK): A

Disney Channel and Disney XD (includes animated shows under Fox Kids and Jetix since Disney XD Europe was originally Fox Kids)
*Kim Possible: A+
*Recess: A
*American Dragon: Jake Long: A
*House of Mouse: A
*Kick Buttowski: Surburban Daredevil: A
*X-Men: TAS: A
*Spider-Man: TAS: A+
*The Replacements: A
*Dave the Barbarian: B
*Fish Hooks: D
*Phineas and Ferb: A
*Lilo and Stitch: A
*Ultimate Spider-Man: F
*Spectacular Spider-Man: A
*Get Ed: A
*House of Mouse: A

Netflix
*Voltron: Legendary Defender: A+
*Trollhunters: A

Sent from my LG-H850 using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

Anthony Riley

Active Member
Apr 11, 2017
145
Ratings
89 4
28
17
#14
Cartoon Network:
Steven Universe: A+
OK KO: A+
Adventure Time: A+
Regular Show: A+
Teen Titans: A+
Teen Titans Go!: F
Powerpuff Girls (1998): A
Powerpuff Girls (2016): F
Samurai Jack: A+
Gumball: A
Codename: Kids Next Door: A
Squirrel Boy: D
Secret Mountain Fort Awesome: F
Ed, Edd, and Eddy: A
Chowder: A
FlapJack: A
Billy and Mandy: A
Camp Lazlo: B
Johnny Bravo: A
Dexter's Lab: A
Nickelodeon:
Spongebob (Seasons 1-4) A+
Fairly Odd Parents (Seasons 1-5) A+
Spongebob (Seasons 5-9) D
Fairly Odd Parents (Seasons 6-10) D-
Hey Arnold!: A+
Rocko's Modern Life: A
CatDog: A
Pig Goat Banana Cricket: F
Sanjay and Craig: C
BreadWinners: F-
Harvey Beaks: A
Angry Beavers: A
Fanboy and ChumChum: F-
Welcome To The Wayne: A
Rugrats: A-
Ren and Stimpy: A-
Invader Zim: A+
Danny Phantom: A
TUFF Puppy: B
Avatar: A+
Disney:
Gravity Falls: A+
Star Vs: A+
Billy Dilley: A
DuckTales (2017): A
DuckTales (1987): A
Kim Possible: A+
Darkwing Duck: A
Pickle and Peanut: F-
Recess: A
Milo Murphie's Law: A
Phineas and Ferb: A-
Lilo and Stich: A
Dave The Barbarian: A
House of Mouse: A
Wander over Yonder: A
Fish Hooks: B-
Right Now Kapow: A-
Penn Zero: B
Tangled: The Series: A-
Kick Buttowski: B-
 

Cartoon Ruler

Senior Member
Dec 11, 2011
4,243
Ratings
1,902 7
113
Galloway, NJ
#15
I've already rated the current Disney cartoons, now I'm grading them this time.

Disney XD
Pickle and Peanut - B
Star vs. the Forces of Evil - B+
Counterfeit Cat - B+
Milo Murphy's Law - A-
Future-Worm! - B
Atomic Puppet - A-
Penn Zero: Part-Time Hero - A-
Star Wars Rebels - A-
Right Now Kapow! - C+
Fangbone! - A-
Two More Eggs - D-

Disney Channel
The ZhuZhus - B-
Mickey Mouse - B+

Nickelodeon
SpongeBob SquarePants - A- (Seasons 1-3), C (Season 4-5), D- (Seasons 6-8), B+ (Seasons 9-)
The Loud House - B+ (pretty good cartoon, but it definitely has its flaws)
Harvey Beaks - A (has been staying constantly great so far)
Pig Goat Banana Cricket - D
Bunsen is a Beast! - C+
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles - B-
Rabbids Invasion - C-
Get Blake! - C (it's Kid vs. Kat done a bit better)
The Fairly OddParents - B (Seasons 1-3), C+ (Seasons 4-8), D (Seasons 9-10)

Cartoon Network
Adventure Time - B
Steven Universe - A-
We Bare Bears - B+
Clarence - B
The Amazing World of Gumball - A-
Mighty Magiswords - B (if there was less pacing, it would've been an B+)
Teen Titans Go! - D (it can have a good episode once in a while, otherwise there's nothing good I can say for this show)
The Powerpuff Girls - C- (a slightly better reboot than TTG, but it ain't that good)
Uncle Grandpa - C- (it's better than Secret Mountain Fort Awesome, but still nothing special)
Supernoobs - D+ (it's more tolerable than Johnny Test, but it's still lame)
My Knight and Me - C
Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs - D+

Boomerang
Be Cool, Scooby-Doo! - B
Bunnicula - B+
Peanuts - A
Shaun the Sheep - A-
Wabbit - B
The Tom and Jerry Show - B+

Discovery Family
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic - C (I'm aware that everyone calls it a great cartoon, but I'm just not really into it)

FOX
Bob's Burgers - B+
Family Guy - C+ (Seasons 1-6), F (Seasons 7-)
The Simpsons - A- (Seasons 1-8), B- (Seasons 9-20), C+ (Seasons 20-)
Here's my updated list (this time, I'm not including shows I don't like).

Nickelodeon

Harvey Beaks (A-)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (A-)
Welcome to the Wayne (B+)
Mysticons (B)
The Loud House (B) *dropped from a B+ to a B; the show has more flaws than I realized
Sanjay and Craig (C+)

Cartoon Network/Boomerang
OK K.O.! Let's Be Heroes! (A-) *IMO, the best currently-running CN series
The Amazing World of Gumball (A-)
Mighty Magiswords (B+) *raised from a B to a B+, due to better pacing in later episodes
We Bare Bears (B+)
Bunnicula (B+)
Regular Show (B+)
Steven Universe (B+)
Adventure Time (B+) *raised from a B to a B+, due to better storytelling in later episodes
Clarence (B)
Be Cool, Scooby-Doo! (B)
Teen Titans Go! (B-) *eventually had second thoughts on this show; I now find it decent at best (despite having its share of bad episodes)
Unikitty! (B-)
Ben 10 (C+) *a better reboot than the awful PPG, but not something I'll go out of my way to watch constantly

Disney XD/Disney Channel
Gravity Falls (A)
Star Wars Rebels (A-)
Mickey Mouse (A-) *raised from a B+ to an A-, due to second thoughts
DuckTales (A-) *does a dang great job being a reboot
Milo Murphy's Law (A-)
Tangled: The Series (A-)
Penn Zero: Part-Time Hero (B+)
Phineas and Ferb (B+)
Wander Over Yonder (B)
Future-Worm! (B)
Star vs. the Forces of Evil (B) *dropped down from a B+ to a B, due to how the shipping drama nonsense is getting in the way of otherwise some good storytelling
Hotel Transylvania: The Series (B)
Right Now Kapow! (B-) *raised from a C+ to a B-; the humor improved in later episodes
Pickle and Peanut (C+)
Billy Dilley's Super-Duper Subterranean Summer (C)

Others
Rick and Morty (A-)
Bojack Horseman (A-)
Bob's Burgers (B+)
 
Last edited:

Fone Bone

Matt Zimmer
Jan 19, 2004
23,858
Ratings
2,464 4
113
42
Framingham, MA
#16
I grade entirely on a curve, so me grading an entire series is pretty much worthless. I judge every episode I review by other episodes of the series, not my highest standards. A five star episode of Power Rangers would probably be worth one star for JLU.
 

ProtoGentIsDead

A cartoon-conspiracy kook
Oct 8, 2017
403
Ratings
266 2
43
16
Omaha, NE
#17
4Kids
EVERY DUBBED THEME SONG FROM ANIME IS TERRIBLE!!!!!!!

Cartoon Network Studios
Adventure Time (A+) [It's gone. Come Along with Me]
Ben 10 (2005) (A)
Ben 10 (2016) (D-)
Camp Lazlo (B+)
Clarence (D+)
Craig of the Creek (A)
Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends (A)
OK K.O.! (A-)
Samurai Jack (A)
Steven Universe (A)
Summer Camp Island (C+)
We Bare Bears (B+)


Nickelodeon
Harvey Beaks (B)
Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (A-)
The Loud House (B-)
Rocko's Modern Life (A-)
Breadwinners (F)
Fanboy and Chum Chum (F)

Disney
Gravity Falls (A)
DuckTales (2017) (A-)
Big City Greens (B)
Amphibia (A-)
Star Vs. TFOE (B+)

Warner Bros.
Animaniacs (B)
Histeria! (C)
Johnny Test (season 1) (C+)
Loonatics Unleashed (D+)
Teen Titans (A)
Teen Titans Go! (D-)
The Looney Tunes Show (2010) (B-)
ThunderCats Roar (F)

Other
Total Dramarama (F+)
CWACOM (2017/Canada) (F)
Johnny Test (seasons 2-6/Canada) (F+)
Care Bears: Unlock the Magic (B-)
Cupcake and Dino: General Services (C)
The Mr. Men Show (B-)
Let's Go Luna! (C)
 
Last edited:

I.R. Shokew

DISGRACED and Rooting ONLY for Underdogs
Sep 26, 2011
9,919
Ratings
1,741 8
113
Who wants to find me that badly anymore?
#18
I grade entirely on a curve, so me grading an entire series is pretty much worthless. I judge every episode I review by other episodes of the series, not my highest standards. A five star episode of Power Rangers would probably be worth one star for JLU.
Yeah... Something tells me if I give most of these shows I've rated another watch, it would be better for a handful of them, but worse off for everything else. After all, taste & opinions (like times in general)? They change.

1) I for one would probably dislike Star Vs. a whole lot more, thanks to Tangled: TAS being far superior watching in every sense for me, personally. I understand what Star Vs. was trying to do; it just didn't work for me.

2a) I still rank Penn Zero: PTH pretty high - unpopular opinion that that is, since I will NEVER EVER understand the hate for it. Basically, a solid Silver Standard. Same case with Big Hero 6: TAS (so far, anyway.), which I'm otherwise happy to see has level-headed fans besides myself.

2b) Ducktales (2017), Milo Murphy's Law, and now Big City Greens have high rankings in my eyes - that wouldn't change too easily, but time has its ways... Maybe Owl House and Amphibia will become that new Gold Standard I'm looking for out of Disney that these examples (plus Tangled: TAS) have provided me so far.

2c) Future-Worm! got a BAD ENDING, so that's definitely lower, now - I still liked it more than I do Rick & Morty, however. Rick & Morty is going to take a turn for the worse, I can just feel it!

3) Don't get me started on how Gumball, Mighty Magiswords (especially, because BAD ENDING.) and Steven Universe (indefinitely and without question) took a real turn for the worse in my eyes. OK K.O. has outpaced ALL 3 of these examples in terms of what I'm looking for out of CN right now that involves a proper mix of action/comedy. I could say the same of Unikitty!, simply for providing some actually good pure slapstick comedy that CN all but lacks in general right now.

4) Loud House even at its most sincere still doesn't hold a candle to Harvey Beaks (RIP its soul) or Craig of the Creek (heck, I even like Summer Camp Island more, in some cases.), TBH with myself. Clarence would be outranked by Craig of the Creek, which is much better, but BOTH are far superior to Loud House (which I'd rank much lower as of late.), honestly. Any of these 3 can beat SCI pretty easily, though, since being OK is the antithesis of actually being good at what you do in the craft.

5) I'd definitely rank Adventure Time & Regular Show just a tad higher than I did in the past for being CN's Gold Standard of Current (Soon to be Past in less than 1.5 years of writing this out) Decade, too (as in not A, but S ranks for both, even if I still think Regular Show is the somewhat better of 2 otherwise near godlike shows.).
 
Last edited:
Dec 11, 2011
4,243
Ratings
1,902 7
113
Galloway, NJ
#19
4Kids
EVERY DUBBED THEME SONG FROM ANIME IS TERRIBLE!!!!!!!

Cartoon Network Studios
Adventure Time (A+) [It's gone. Come Along with Me]
Ben 10 (2005) (A)
Ben 10 (2016) (D-)
Camp Lazlo (B+)
Clarence (D+)
Craig of the Creek (A)
Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends (A)
OK K.O.! (A-)
Samurai Jack (A)
Steven Universe (A)
Summer Camp Island (C+)
We Bare Bears (B+)


Nickelodeon
Harvey Beaks (B)
Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (A-)
The Loud House (B-)
Rocko's Modern Life (A-)
Breadwinners (F)
Fanboy and Chum Chum (F)

Disney
Gravity Falls (A)
DuckTales (2017) (A-)
Big City Greens (B)
Amphibia (A-)
Star Vs. TFOE (B+)

Warner Bros.
Animaniacs (B)
Histeria! (C)
Johnny Test (season 1) (C+)
Loonatics Unleashed (D+)
Teen Titans (A)
Teen Titans Go! (D-)
The Looney Tunes Show (2010) (B-)
ThunderCats Roar (F)

Other
Total Dramarama (F+)
CWACOM (2017/Canada) (F)
Johnny Test (seasons 2-6/Canada) (F+)
Care Bears: Unlock the Magic (B-)
Cupcake and Dino: General Services (C)
The Mr. Men Show (B-)
Let's Go Luna! (C)
Some of those shows you've listed hasn't even premiered yet.
 

SourSweetGone

Canterlot High Class of 83.
Aug 7, 2018
197
Ratings
124 2
28
27
US
#20
Most cartoons are good IMHO so I would give them A grade of "Yes, more please" and "You rock [insert show staff here!]"

The few cartoons I would give failing grades I feel best just not to talk about. "Out of sight out of mind"

Then most anime I would rate "No thank you" "bad touch" or "why would you make that!?"