Fullmetal Alchemist vs Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood

Discussion in 'The Anime Forum' started by Manga4life, Apr 11, 2012.

  1. Manga4life

    Manga4life DYNAMITE's PULP FIESTA BLOG!!!

    Joined:
    Feb 8, 2010
    Messages:
    6,739
    Location:
    U.S.A
    So, which series did you guys prefer and why? Which one was truly better than the other? For me, it was really hard for me to go into Brotherhood because I was such a huge fan of the original FMA that the thought of me enjoying Brotherhood more was just unimaginable, but then I sat down and watched Brotherhood and I can honestly say that I do enjoy it better than the original. Not a whole lot better, but just slightly because of the stronger animation and the fact that it just felt "different" than the original Fullmetal Alchemist.

    I do still hold a torch for the original FMA though, and many of the sad and epic moments of Brotherhood were dulled because I saw them first in the original, so stuff such as Hughes' funeral and Dr. Tucker turning his child into a beast didn't hit me nearly as much as they did in the original show. Any which way, I loved both series and I would certainly recommend either to anyone who wants to get into the genre or who's just looking for a show with a tremendous overall story, but for me the choice goes to Brotherhood because I felt the overall product was just a little better when it comes to story and animation, but the music of the original still shined brighter in my opinion.
     
  2. Divinenega

    Divinenega New Member

    Joined:
    Aug 13, 2010
    Messages:
    1,124
    Location:
    Montclair, NJ
    Seeing as I read the manga before I watched the first anime, Brotherhood is my favorite of the two since it is the one more faithful to the manga storyline. That being said I do like the original series and despite going off in it;s own direction it did a solid job of doing so and told an excellent story.

    Though if I have one major complaint about the old series it's the movie which ultimately accomplished nothing but ruining the ending to the TV series and further kicking Ed in the balls.
     
  3. Bryangst

    Bryangst JERK

    Joined:
    Aug 28, 2003
    Messages:
    1,338
    Location:
    Portland, OR
    I really didn't know what to expect going into Brotherhood. I knew that Brotherhood was more faithful to the manga but I didn't read any of it beforehand. So to see the differences between the two develop was really interesting. Either way I am a fan of both series', but I am enjoying Brotherhood far more.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 12, 2012
  4. Chaos Yoshi Mage

    Chaos Yoshi Mage The Lonely Raven

    Joined:
    Jul 19, 2009
    Messages:
    4,032
    Location:
    IL
    The original, I just felt that it's story had much more meaning delving into the psychology and philosophy of it's characters. Brotherhood was more of a traditional fantasy show, a good one, but not the greatness of the first show.
     
  5. RockmanDash

    RockmanDash Retired

    Joined:
    Apr 4, 2005
    Messages:
    17,012
    The first twenty five episodes of FMA(2003) was top notch awesome. However, after that the plot just went into a really bad bitter direction that just didn't leave a powerful impact on me at all. It's fine to make a bitter sweet ending that feels realistic, but Bones just couldn't reach that powerful feeling when it was time to conclude everything. The movie was where it was meant to count the most with the ending and I was slightly disgusted with how the characters' fates were handled.

    Brotherhood completely got me hooked again to the series and I was really happy with the way the story progressed. We got to see more of the world and all the new characters just made the experience even more enjoyable. I was very, very curious if I was going to like the ending and luckily I loved every ounce of it.
     
  6. Luna

    Luna Daydreamer

    Joined:
    Apr 2, 2002
    Messages:
    5,158
    Location:
    Fantasy Land
    I'd give a slight edge to Brotherhood,since I liked the ending more,and since it was more faithful to the manga,some of the characters I liked who didn't make it into the first anime (or only got a brief cameo),were finally animated,like Ling,Mei,and Olivier...
    However,some of the dramatic scenes that appeared in both series were handled better in the original (what happens to Hughes,and what Shou Tucker did to his daughter and dog)...
     
  7. Magus

    Magus Big Boss

    Joined:
    Oct 24, 2008
    Messages:
    3,698
    Location:
    Michigan
    Easy answer for me. Brotherhood. While they had their good moments in the original, Ed and Al practically ruined it for me, whereas, in Brotherhood, they are far more enjoyable.

    If Ed and Al were tolerable in the original this would definately be a harder decision because everything and everyone else in the original was really good.
     
  8. SecretAgent94

    SecretAgent94 New Member

    Joined:
    Feb 22, 2011
    Messages:
    288
    Location:
    Mars
    The first 25-ish episodes are a better introduction to the series and leave a stronger impact. They pretty much take the manga stories and make them better in everyway.At it's peak it was easily masterpiece material in my opinion. However, after that it all goes to ****.

    The first 13 or so episodes of Brotherhood are lackluster compared to the 2003 series version and are a poor introduction to the series. But as soon as it starts to seperate from the first series, it is an excellent watch and stomps all over the 2003 series.
     
  9. O-chan

    O-chan Active Member

    Joined:
    Nov 12, 2004
    Messages:
    2,644
    While I agree with everyone the first series improve upon the manga counterpart, I don't agree with the rest of the story was awful. I've seen many anime that detoured from the manga and FMA was one of the few ones that managed to keep characterization strong and plot engaging. In hindsight, especially after the original movie's ending, and double that once the manga, and second anime was done I could see valid criticisms but at the time I personally felt Bones did an excellent job on the series from beginning to end.

    O-chan
     
  10. Manga4life

    Manga4life DYNAMITE's PULP FIESTA BLOG!!!

    Joined:
    Feb 8, 2010
    Messages:
    6,739
    Location:
    U.S.A
    Looks like Brotherhood seems to the the favorite among the FMA fans here on Toonzone, I can totally see why too due to its amazing storyline and great animation. I am surprised the original show didn't get as many nods as it did, but I remain a fan of both and will continue to enjoy them for many more years, I'm sure.
     

Share This Page