I loved the Disney Afternoon. I watched it as often as possible.
My favorite was Duck Tales. The adventure-feel to the show was what drew me in, and the characters kept me there. My interest did wain when Bubba entered, but not enough to keep me away. I'm still hoping that one day we'll get an Uncle Scrooge plush toy.
My second favorite was Chi n' Dale's Rescue Rangers. The equipment that Gadget made always intrigued me, and the crimes they had to solve were interesting enough to my impressinable young mind.
Now, Gargoyles was never on the Disney Afternoon here. Neither was Aladdin, or Bonkers as far as I remember. Darkwing Duck was shown weekday mornings at 7 on the CBS affiliate, with Gargoyles on the UPN affiliate at 7 (years after DW) and Aladdin @ 8:30 or 9. I hadn't heard of Bonkers until I began searching the net for Duck Tales sites last year.
My least favorite is Bonkers, which I've had the chance to see thanks to Toon Disney. Mind you, I've only seen a few eps, and I have a huge nostalgia for the programs that encompsed the Disney Afternoon I remember - Duck Tales, Chip n' Dale, TaleSpin, and Goof Troop.