-Depends.Originally posted by The Spirit
Heres a question that should lead to some interesting
In a battle royale - who wins ? The Justice League or the Xmen?
Now considering the Xmen are now an army practically ,
I am going to limit the Xmen to some of the usual suspects .
-considering the power differential, that isn't really necessary
Heres the Xmen Team :
Cyclops : Jean Grey: Colosus : Wolverine : Gambit: Rogue :
The Justice League :
Superman : Wonder Woman: Green Lantern: Martian Manhunter:
The Flash : Batman : Plastic Man
Who wins ?
I think , on the surface it appears that the Justice League has
the Xmen beat just based on the big guns JL brings to the battle
- Superman , WWoman, Green Lantern , and MManhunter are
indivually forces to be reckoned with.
Thats why for now Im trying to point out advantages the
Xmen may have to balance the playing field.
* * * *
Do you think Wolverines Adamantium Claws can penetrate
I think this is the deciding factor here , because the only way for the Xmen to win is to nuetralize Superman. I think if Wolverine
can cut Superman - we have a match.
-They probably can. However, there are other ways to take down Supes: telepathy, power draining. Not to mention that Cyclops, at least, packs enough punch to at least hurt Supes.
Rogue is another Xmen who would be able to nuetralize superman by absorbing his powers ...then maybee utilizing
her combined power with supes strength to take out Wonder Woman.
I think it would be up to Jean Grey to nuetralize Martian Manhunter with her telepathy.
-She is far better at offense than he is, and has a better tutor.
What does everyone think ?
How would this play out - although considering the
forum this question is bieng posed in - Id say JL has home court
Lets try to be fair and unbiased.
If they fight as in the comic book, the X-Men should win, simply because the heavy hitters of the JLA almost never use their full potential, where as the X-Men regularly do. Also, if the JLA does something stupid ( letting Kyle lead ), they are gonna eat it.
If they fight smart ( by CBUB rules ), JLA wins in one picosecond. Superspeed, superspeed, superspeed. Note that the JLA almost never exploit their superspeed in combat, so that is why the above is different.
If they fight as in the cartoon, who knows?? If it was the old Superfriends vs. X-Men argument, than X-Men take it, easily, but the new JL will probably be more effective ( I hope ).