PDA

View Full Version : The Underdwellers = Underrated?



Russkafin
05-30-2003, 12:35 AM
I just got the new Batman: Tales of the Dark Knight DVD today for my birthday, and popped it in the ol' DVD player. I watched The Underdwellers, even though I remembered it as being an episode I would usually turn off when it came on TV back in the day, because I didn't really like it.

In retrospect, it was a lot better than I remembered.

It certainly wasn't the best BTAS had to offer... far from it, actually. But, there were a few highlights.

The Bruce/Alfred interaction. Alfred: "Perhaps you need a vacation, sir? Golf?" Bruce: "Sounds boring." Alfred: "The bahamas?" Bruce: "Hot and boring." By the time we got to TNBA, we lost those fun little interactions between Bruce and his butler in the Batcave.

Then, the whole sequence with Alfred and the kid, where the kid is stealing the silverware and sliding down the stairs, and Alfred is chasing him around. That was priceless! Alfred was a real gem on this show, man, and Zimbalist Jr.'s voice was dead-on. He was a man who'd seen it all and yet was still being put through the wringer, and he was a riot all the while. His sarcasm, his sense of timing... I freaking love Alfred.

Last but not least, the best part is when Batman freaking loses it in the sewer and starts ringing that bell like crazy, and breaks it! Batman almost flipped his lid when he saw how those kids were being treated. And then, when he pulls the sewer king from the train tracks? "I don't decide your fate, that's up to the courts... but this time, I am sorely tempted to do the job myself!" How many other times do you remember Batman basically saying he wanted to kill someone????

The Underdwellers... a masterpiece? No. But it was way better than I had remembered, and I was glad to revisit an old BTAS episode that I had almost let slip by me.

Digu Volz
05-30-2003, 12:55 AM
Ah yes, a more human Batman... Blame Frank Miller.

TimTwoFace
05-30-2003, 01:50 AM
This episode is by no means a great episode, but it's not crap, either. It's a pretty run-of-the-mill "nameless villain" story with a few fun quirks thrown in - especially exemplified with Alfred and his "ward" at Wayne Manor. :p A lot of the little things were off in this episode, like Batman's dialogue - it was still shaky and not brilliantly written. I actually thought the Sewer King was an interesting villain - nothing that is worthy of a second episode, but he was a good one-shot kinda guy.

-Tim

Patrick Bateman
05-30-2003, 01:57 AM
Then, the whole sequence with Alfred and the kid, where the kid is stealing the silverware and sliding down the stairs, and Alfred is chasing him around. That was priceless! Alfred was a real gem on this show, man, and Zimbalist Jr.'s voice was dead-on. He was a man who'd seen it all and yet was still being put through the wringer, and he was a riot all the while. His sarcasm, his sense of timing... I freaking love Alfred.
My sentiments exactly. Nothing beats his line "Rise and shine, Master Leprechaun." That one has me in stitches every time. :D

Good Ol' Batmanuel!
05-31-2003, 03:34 PM
I love it. Both me and my brother (who usually prefers the more action-oriented episodes) were pretty impressed by it, mostly by how quiet it was. It gave it a weird feeling, not having so much music in it. In the end, it's not a great episode, but I've always enjoyed it a lot, so I do feel it is underrated.

Maybe part of it is because I'm a sucker for the more "human" stories, as one of my top five favorites is "It's Never Too Late," one that I think is amazing, but which my brother felt was kinda boring. Go figure. :rolleyes:

Mister Intensity
06-01-2003, 10:33 AM
I always thought this was one of the more underrated episodes. While it wasn't one of the more high profile early episodes, I was always struck by Batman related to the children in the story and how it closely it parallels Batman's own childhood on a certain level. Maybe that's why this episode works for me.

Mister Intensity

Reptile_Orion
06-02-2003, 07:02 PM
Ah yes, a more human Batman... Blame Frank Miller.


I loved Frank Miller's Batman. DKR and Year One rock. But DK2 was horrible :) .

The Underdwellers does have it moments but it is not an episode that I am dying to watch.