PDA

View Full Version : Spider-Man/Black Cat - too much of an adult slant? (spoilers)



slackermonkey
10-19-2002, 07:45 PM
I've been hearing complaints about how the Spider-Man/Black Cat mini-series isn't as age-friendly as a Spidey comic should be. With the first two issues, there were numerous risque jokes, comments on Black Cat's breasts, references to child molestation, and a plot that involved drug use (we even see numerous characters go through the effects of od-ing).

But issue #3 REALLY pushed it. For those who don't know, the story began to take a darker tone, with butchered bodies, a blood-splattered (but still very much alive) baby, and in the end, Black Cat finds herself feeling the effects of heroin, incapacitating her and leaving her vulnerable to Mr. Brownstone, where it is suggested that he will rape/has raped her.

Personally, I enjoy this new take on Spidey. The stories are edgier and more refreshing than they have been in years, though I do think Smith's sense of humor is a little too lowbrow at times. There's an obvious darker tone, but it keeps a familiar slant to remind us it's a Spidey book. My point is, how do you feel about the overall tone of Spider-Man/Black Cat? Comments?

rggkjg1
10-19-2002, 09:11 PM
well. it is kevin smith after all. i dont think he could ever write anything that would be "pg". the lowest i feel he can go is "pg-13". proof being these issues. but it really doest matter. as i've said before, kevin smith can write anything and it could be total crap and still sell millions and get high praise.

czyznyck99
10-19-2002, 09:46 PM
I like it so far. It's no more adult than the MAX books, that's for sure. The banter between Spidey/Cat caught me off-balance, though, it did seem a little racy at times, even more so when compared to Ultimate Spider-man. On the other hand that is a great comparison between the young, eager hero, and the older, torn avenger :) .

Later.

sulimo
10-19-2002, 10:26 PM
I'm really liking it...I wonder if this a prelude of things to come when Kevin takes over ASM?

Cogliostro
10-20-2002, 12:21 AM
I really like it. It shows the true evil that superhero's have to taken on and that some of the worse villians are the one's not wearing the mask. As for this take on Spiderman I don't think it will be carried over to Amazing Spiderman when Smith jumps on the title. I wouldn't mind seeing more of it though...