Favorite B&W Mickey Mouse Cartoon

[Nelson]

What is your favorite Mickey Mouse Cartoon?

[Pietro]

"Steamboat Willie" is definitely the greatest Mickey Mouse cartoon of all time so I voted for that.

-Pietro

[hippety hopper]

There 2 Mickey cartoon's I really like "Steamboat willie" and "Mickeys mellodrama".
Because I had to decide I like Mickeys mellodrama more.
I like the way he sticks the TNT in his mouth to get a blackface and the way everything goes wrong!

[Nelson]

I had to go for as my favorite Mickey Mouse cartoon "Touchdown Mickey".It is so funny for a football cartoon, and the scene where the fat pig steamrolls over the oposing team leaving them flat as a pancake is a classic.

[David Gerstein]

I chose THE KARNIVAL KID because it's my favorite Mickey cartoon to watch with others.
Lots of Mickey cartoons are great, but KARNIVAL lets my friends see that (A) Mickey can be a funny character, (B) Disney cartoons can include slapstick violence, (C) Disney cartoons can be gross, and (D) Disney cartoons can be weird. Lots of people have no idea that these four facts are true... and in the process, they not only get a surprise, they laugh themselves tired!
I also like the villain Kat Nipp, who never had a major role again, but was good for a few laughs in the comics (where he did the same kind of thing he did here... abuse Mickey's nose and tail).
My favorite Mickey cartoon, period, is THE GALLOPIN' GAUCHO, which wasn't in the poll.

[Sveven Dvorking]

I have never seen any B&W Mickey cartoons in full, but voted for Steamboat Willie, because I saw part of it and I heard from other people that it was one of the best.

[Thad Komorowski]

I voted "Steamboat Willie". It's by far the greatest Mickey Mouse cartoon of all time!

-Thad:D

[Cartman]

I really don't have a single favorite B&W Mickey short, but if I had to chose, I would have to go with MICKEY'S MELLERDRAMMER. I enjoy cartoons that feature black caricatures (but I'm not a racist person) and MICKEY'S MELLERDRAMMER has a lot of fun gags such as when Clarabelle takes soot from an old lamp and rubs it on her face, making her look like a black person and when Mickey sticks a firecracker in his mouth and it explodes in his face.

Other B&W Mickey shorts I enjoy are THE MOOSE HUNT, STEAMBOAT WILLIE, PLANE CRAZY, THE BARNYARD BATTLE, THE CHAIN GANG-- to name a few.:D

[Glenn]

I'm waiting for the Mickey Mouse B&W's to come in. Then I'll be able to make a decision.

Glenn

[BourgeoisBuffoon]

Steamboat Willie! The first one is always gonna be a classic! I still chuckle when he has the boat blow the horn....that's the kinda scene that stays in cartoon history.

(looks at post)

Man, I REALLY gotta make more sense...