PDA

View Full Version : Why "Smallville's" Clark Kent is way cooler than "Superman" news article...



DR.MID-NITE
07-22-2006, 09:46 AM
The following article appeared in The Seattle Times....
:D


Why "Smallville's" Clark Kent is way cooler than "Superman"

By Julia Waterhous
Special To The Seattle Times

http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/ABPub/2006/07/18/2003135385.jpg (http://javascript<b></b>:PopoffWindow('2003135555','750','675','http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/ABPub/zoom/html/2003135555.html','yes','no');)
http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/art/ui/zoom_photo.gif (http://javascript<b></b>:PopoffWindow('2003135555','750','675','http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/ABPub/zoom/html/2003135555.html','yes','no');)
Tom Welling, as Clark Kent on "Smallville." Brandon Routh, right, in title role of "Superman Returns."


With the "Superman Returns" movie just out, the Superman hype of the '80s has been kick-started all over again. But while watching the movie, you can't help but wonder, how did Clark Kent get to be Superman? What was his childhood like? He couldn't have been a journalist at the Daily Planet forever.
That, my friends, is where "Smallville" comes in. In my opinion, it's TV's coolest show, and way cooler than the "Superman" film.
When you think about it, it's a great premise. Superman fans know all about the villains Superman's fought, his powers and adventures, and some bare-bones information about his background. But how did a Super-man get that way? We knew some things about his childhood, but not in fleshed-out detail — not, that is, until the 2001 debut on The WB of "Smallville."
Here's why we tune in week after week, after more than 100 episodes:
1. The story lines. The plots are really complex; in one recent episode Clark goes to Jor-El to try to save someone he loved who recently died, but in doing this, he sacrifices his previous happiness and his father ends up dying instead. But at the same time, the overall story is simple, because we know how it's going to end. But this doesn't make it any less exciting. Far from it, it makes the show almost even more exciting because there are certain characters that you just can't imagine how they turn out the way they do, or how they wouldn't be a part of Clark's life as a grown man.
2. The girls. If the grown-up Clark Kent's lover is Lois Lane, what on earth will happen to Lana? And the Lois of "Smallville" is so hard-headed and stubborn that Clark finds her downright obnoxious — so how and when, exactly, do they turn into lovers? Plus, although Clark and Lex Luthor aren't exactly getting along, they don't hate each other. What's going to happen that's so drastic it would turn them into arch-enemies?
3. Clark's inner turmoil. Clark has this HUGE secret that he is trying to hide from the world (having superpowers and all), and it's absolutely agonizing watching him hide it from the ones he loves — just because he's trying to protect them. But we can all relate to Clark. Each and every one of us has a secret that we don't want others to know, that we're afraid if someone found out it might change how they see us. Seeing this played out in "Smallville" absolutely makes your heart go out to Clark.
4. Jor-El. Jor-El — nothing but a disembodied voice, really — is unique to "Smallville." He's a complete mystery to everyone, including Clark, and you can never tell whether his intentions are good or bad. Is he trying to help Clark save humanity — or destroy it?
5. What can I say? Tom Welling is absolutely gorgeous. Would "Smallville" be the same with a different actor playing Clark? Why are you even asking?
6. Clark Kent is so ... good. There is no other word for it, and that — not his superpowers — is what makes him un-human. He always does what is right, and although people strive to be that virtuous, nobody is truly capable of it.
But Clark remains pure and good, despite his list of problems. He struggles to fit in at high school just like everybody else. He has girl problems, goes through hormone swings, gets teased and bullied. ("I want you to remember this day, Clark," Lex says ominously one day. "I want you to remember that despite all your amazing powers, there was one man that beat you.")
In short, someone so good has a life that's so hard; a life in which very few people actually know who you are. A life in which you struggle every day to protect your family and friends, feel the weight of the world every time somebody gets hurt. Where you put everybody else first — despite a friend like Martha saying, "Clark, it's not your responsibility to save everybody!" — and never think once about what is best for you.
"Smallville," unlike the big-screen "Superman," manages to touch the viewer intimately, and makes you want to reach out to Clark and make his life OK — because he deserves it more than anybody else.
Julia Waterhous is a high-school student in Oregon: jsw_618@yahoo.com (jsw_618@yahoo.com) or vwaterhous@msn.com (vwaterhous@msn.com)

Wonderwall
07-22-2006, 10:46 AM
Im going to have to agree and disagree with that article. See Smallville in its first 3 seasons was good and might've been able to be called the coolest show on TV. However Smallville has really tanked and spent the last 2 seasons on the other side of the spectrum. The storylines used to be good, now they suffer from mischaracterization, plot twists that range on the ludicrous, stealing ideas from movies( Sawville anyone?) and not even using them right, repeated plot lines, how many times has Clark gone bad, or someone stole his powers, or him and Lex fight and are bitter enemies yet the next week everything's fine. The girls are hot in Smallville, cant complain there Lana, Lois, Chloe(;) ), Alicia, Feromone chick, Native american girl( yea I dont remember their names ). 2 of the last 3 had quite the effect in what few episodes they were in, and they did really good in them too. And its sad that Alicia showed more growth in 3 episodes then Lana has in 5 seasons. Shes still a bratty, self absorbed, magically rich annoyance who the writers could have salvaged by having her die instead of J Kent. Lois is funny but pointless, theres no reason for her to be there, and no one can say different. Only Chloe has been consistently good, especially in season 5 where she was the only highlight. Clark's inner turmoil has been played, theres no reason to keep his powers a secret to Lana, seeing as he uses his powers all the time in front of strangers. Jor El is cool, that I cant disagree, but half the reason is that General Zod, Terrance Stamp plays his voice. I got no beef with Welling, I believe him as Clark, who these days is as slow witted as a lemming. To say that for all that Smallville's Clark is cooler than Supes..i dont think so.

Peter Paltridge
07-22-2006, 02:03 PM
Welling is not that cool. If you were locked in a closet with him you'd go insane.

Julia Waterhaus is strange.

Terminatah
07-22-2006, 03:54 PM
This article ignores the fact that Smallville has sucked for the past few seasons. It's a show that was really good when it first started, but now, nothing cool is happening. For example, when the show started, Lex was a well-intentioned person whose path to the dark side stemmed from having his father's sins tarnishing his name. Now he's just evil for no reason, and he doesn't ever do anything interesting because he's always getting tied up or beaten or shot. Lionel's motivations for the past billion episodes have been a complete friggin mystery to the audience. It's like the writers can't decide what to do with him. Chloe has mutated into a magical hacker that would never exist in the real world. You don't just google impossible surveillance camera footage from high-security buildings. All the back-and-forth relationship stuff with Lana has poisoned the show with interminable go-nowhere stories. You could take all the development their relationship has ever endured and knock it out in one episode. And of course, we've gotten more witches and vampires than one should ever have to see on a Superman-related show. If I had to guess when this show got really crappy, I'd say it was right after the third season. Before that, it was one of my favorite shows. My favorite episode was "Memoria," where we learned what happened to Lex's baby brother and got a good glimpse into Lex's childhood. In fact, Michael Rosenbaum and John Glover are the clear MVPs of the show and the only reason I still watch it is them (not that anyone else in the cast is subpar; they're just my favorites).

-Terminatah

Simpler Simon
07-22-2006, 07:10 PM
Um, the article was a space-filler, written by a high school student in Oregon (!) to pad out the Times' Lifestyle section one day last week.

No wonder the first few lines read like garbage.

mookie75
07-22-2006, 07:54 PM
Um, the article was a space-filler, written by a high school student in Oregon (!) to pad out the Times' Lifestyle section one day last week.

Which doesn't necessarily make her less qualified than any normal newspaper critic. :evil:

Icer
07-22-2006, 08:11 PM
I enjoy Smallville as much as anyone, but this article is crap.

Master Moron
07-22-2006, 08:47 PM
Um, the article was a space-filler, written by a high school student in Oregon (!) to pad out the Times' Lifestyle section one day last week.

Hmmmm...that explains the use of the term "way cooler". Not that I never use the term, just not something I'd expect to see in a professional article.

Sr.Infierno
07-22-2006, 08:51 PM
Still better then half the crap my fellow high school newpaper staff puts out.

Peter Paltridge
07-23-2006, 03:55 AM
Um, the article was a space-filler, written by a high school student in Oregon (!) to pad out the Times' Lifestyle section one day last week.
Does that exclamation point express contempt for a high-school student, or for someone from Oregon?

Yes, I am pretty easily offended.....