South Park "Erection Day" Talkback (SPOILERS)

[NickWhiz1]

Jimmy has to get control of his raging hormones in time to perform in the school's talent show.
A Jimmy-centric episode...this should be interesting.

Did Barbrady's voice change? It doesn't sound quite right.

[Juu-kuchi]

Dr. Pal... indeed. Too much of a pal.

[Spongebrain2.0]

Holy Crap...Do Trey & Matt do this on purpose, as in saving the best episodes of all time for the end of the season. This is quite possibly the funniest SP episode I have seen in years:D

[Juu-kuchi]

...This is depraved. Yet for some reason hilarious.

There's something funny about a handicapped 10-year old kid carrying a rather heavyset hooker to that tune.

[Spongebrain2.0]

After a half season of modestly funny episodes. This episode proves that SP is not losing steam. Man, this one was classic!:anime:

[Shark]

Wow, Jimmy going through the car chase, getting shot, finally getting laid, and in the end, all for nothing. Hilarious!

Good Points:
-Goth band's song about how talent shows are gay.
-Butters (I swear, everything he does is funny)
-... AHHH! Darn this terrible short term memory of mine!

[Happy]

It was okay but the episode that aired before was funnier. I did love their take on authentic Italian restraunts and talent shows though.

[shoujoaifan]

I'm going to sound like a total SP newbie, which I am (although I've seen a few, like the Christmas one with Mr. Hanky, parts of the movie, and the one where the boys keep pulling hoaxes on the two guys on public acess), so here was my reaction:

"......Wow.....Haha.......WOW.....HAHAHA........WOW"

(I'm betting this is a pretty common reaction for SP newbies, right?)

Although I was expecting a different ending. I was kinda expecting the school and his parents to find out he had sex with a prostitute and then explaining how not only will he not get laid all the time, but you shouldn't do that anyway, and then something shock value, like him getting a disease and/or getting the prostitute pregnant.

I take it the joke with him being such a lousy comedian but everyone laughing is because they pity him for being disabled, right?

[Ktkb3@aol.com]

Jimmy carried the Hooker "Officer and a Gentleman" stlye was hilarious! i coulden't stop laughing. Jimmy had a hard time controling himself when he heard the little bells ringing noise everytime he got an erection. :D I also liked Butters peeing himself when he got embarrassed and Ms. Garrision had to clean up his pee. That was funny! :)

This episode was funny and Jimmy had a lot of screen time. I think South Park still has it with the comedy and good ideas. I can't wait to see what they got in store for the eighth and final episode to end the first half of season 9

[Fone Bone]

This was so wrong and so right at the exact same time.

Well, it looks like Jimmy's learned what ALL boys have to come to realize: There is NO way to permanently unpitch a tent.

Sneezing milk. Nut Gobbler. Nice.

Cartman's been laid over 5000 times? Wow, I never would have guessed.

Best parody of An Officer and a Gentlemen since The Simpsons Life in the Fast Lane.

You've got to be kidding me! Best. Closing. Line. EVER!

Score (HA!): ****1/2. Really. I never thought about it that way. That is SO interesting.

[NickWhiz1]

The chase scene seriously has to be one of the best sequences in the series. I love how Jimmy is virtually unphased after getting shot in the shoulder. Gogogo cartoonage!

Jimmy had to learn what all us guys have learned the hard way :( Still, the girls have got it worse IMO.

[RD!]

Juvenile garbage... I thought I'd never actually say that myself about an SP episode but come on... this was total garbage.

[TnAdct1]

When it comes to the talent show part, all I can say is this: Screw Jimmy. Give me the Goths "anti-talent show" song and Cartman's impression of Al Pacino in Scarface. :D

[90'sCartoonMan]

Gonna have to disagree Strawberry Jam. In South Park terms, I don't think it was that juvenille. What guy on here didn't sympathize with Jimmy? I sure did. Of course, it doesn't go that far, but it's kind of funny. I liked Cartman as the White Hitch. Jimmy's one of my favorite characters, so of course I'd like this episode. Great ending.

[Zero Signal]

Okay, now that was a classic episode. I've liked all of them this season, but this was the best of the bunch (so far). For some reason I tend to really enjoy episodes that focus on people other than the main four. Since Butters and Jimmy are two of my favorites, I was really happy.

The Highlights:
--Dr. Pal was sick and wrong on so many levels, but I just couldn't quit laughing. Totally wrong.
--The earpiece Jimmy wore on his date. I kinda saw the joke coming, but it was still great.
--Cartman's advice was amazing, and Jimmy's delivery of the lines had me rolling.
--Poor Butters. They pick on that kid so much, I'm surprised he hasn't snapped. Hopefully it's leading to a return of Professor Chaos.
--Best. Car. Chase. Ever. It just kept building and getting funnier, and I loved him paying the $6 from the top of the car.
--Those Goth kids rule. It wouldn't be so funny if it wasn't just like a bunch of kids I went to high school with.
--Cartman doing Scarface caught me off guard. I love that movie to death, and Eric did an awesome job with some great lines.
--Officer and a Gentleman song was perfect. That whole scene was great.
--"You've got to be kidding me!" Fone Bone is right, that's probably the best closing line the show has done.

Great episode. 4 and 1/2 pitched tents from me.

[TurtleTitan]

Pretty funny. Things I liked:

- The "dingaling" noise when an erection was coming
- Sneezing milk
- "Oh yeah I've gotten laid like 1000 times" + Cartman's advice
- Cartman's Scarface
- The car chase + "Here's your money" (on top of the car)
- "You've gotta be kidding me."

I think Barbrady's voice seemed off. And, aside from the ending quote, it could've used a better ending...Jimmy actually had sex with her :ack:

[HomeMoviesFan]

I take it the joke with him being such a lousy comedian but everyone laughing is because they pity him for being disabled, right?
No, the town idolizes Jimmy for his jokes. In fact, he's got some pretty funny ones in past eps this time. The joke, I guess, this time was that Jimmy was trying to do current events, and instead of doing some funny stuff, Trey decided to just joke around with how current they can get and not focus on the "punchline" (since half of the jokes didn't get their punchline anyway tonight)...

Anyways...wow...that wasn't as screwed up as "Woodland Critter Christmas"...it was much MORE screwed up than it!! Especially Jimmy and the prostitute (though I was expecting a Sin City parody)...oh, jeez, classic stuff here...

[Classic Speedy]

Did Barbrady's voice change? It doesn't sound quite right. I noticed that too. He sounded like a mother who's babytalking her toddler. :shrug:

Anyway, it was pretty hilarious all the way through, with the biggest highlight being the chase scene. Every time Jimmy opens his mouth he cracks me up because of how fast he talks. His stand-up is almost exactly like Leno's, too. It was so great hearing him say "There's not much time until the talent show!" as a reason for wanting to get laid. :p

Line of the night, besides the ending, came from Mr. Mackey, after Jimmy confides in him about his erection in class: "Oh Jimmy's just pitching his tent". :D GRADE: A-

[Stewie]

Meh. During a commercial break I switched to ATHF. By the time I remembered to go back, the car chase was over and Jimmy was already on stage.
I wouldn't say I cared that I missed it.

[Juu-kuchi]

...Did anybody get a big laugh at how Butters uses the urinal?

[candy17]

Next to the episode where Paris Hilton comes to town (Stupid Spoiled Whore Playset, I think it's called), this is so far the best episode I've seen so far (and because of school, I usually miss it). As someone else said, this episode proves that South Park isn't running out of steam just yet (I'd give it another two years, but not likely).

[TnAdct1]

Anyways...wow...that wasn't as screwed up as "Woodland Critter Christmas"...it was much MORE screwed up than it!! Especially Jimmy and the prostitute (though I was expecting a Sin City parody)...oh, jeez, classic stuff here... You know, I kinda wondered if the introduction to the prostitute area was a crack at Sin City.

[SirLemming]

...Did anybody get a big laugh at how Butters uses the urinal?Yes, definitely.

Overall, this episode could've been better, but for this season it was good.

[Spongebrain2.0]

This episode was possibly one of the best SP episodes I have ever seen. Not one scene bored me, This was fantastic. I can't wait for this one to hit DVD!:D

[Master Moron]

...Did anybody get a big laugh at how Butters uses the urinal?

Huh? What do you mean, I didn't notice anything unusual about how he uses the urinal.

Anyway, this episode was okay, but not all that great. It started out pretty good. The whole "Can I stick my penis in your vagina" lines were pretty funny. But, I really don't think Butters is all that funny. I almost never laugh at anything he does. Him peeing his pants and asking Cartman for a courtesy flush wasn't funny. Was it even supposed to be? And the gross out jokes like a guy getting his head stuck in the prostitute's vagina really weren't funny. Also, I don't see why everybody thinks the "You've got to be kidding me" line was so funny. I thought it was kind of stupid. Anyway, this episode wasn't nearly as funny as the last two or the sex change episode, but it was a lot better than that awful Terry Schilo episode.

[Sandoz]

Best episode of the season, but still pretty so-so. It didn't really pick up until the car chase and the other talent show acts performed (love those Goth kids). I know this is South Park and nothing should really shock me anymore, but I was still put off at the implication that Jimmy actually had sex with that prostitute. Meh.


You know, I kinda wondered if the introduction to the prostitute area was a crack at Sin City. No, it was a parody of a documentary series about urban prostitution that ran on HBO some time ago (unfortunately I can't remember its name :sad: ). The narrator's voice and the hip, "poetic" introduction were taken straight from that.

[Mr. Insomnia]

...People sure have low as **** standards for entertainment. Seriously, an episode about erections. Come on people. Worst. Episode. Ever.

[Spongebrain2.0]

...People sure have low as **** standards for entertainment. Seriously, an episode about erections. Come on people. Worst. Episode. Ever.

Did you even watch this. It sounds like you're just pretending you did. This was hilarious. It was great. You can always trust Trey & Matt for huge season finales, (Woodland Critter Christmas, Erection Day)

[SirLemming]

Huh? What do you mean, I didn't notice anything unusual about how he uses the urinal.He, like, dropped his pants all the way down and lifted up his shirt, or something. It looked really funny.
Also, simply because this will continue to annoy me in every South Park talkback, it's "Terry Schiavo". Not "Schilo".

...People sure have low as **** standards for entertainment. Seriously, an episode about erections. Come on people. Worst. Episode. Ever.Simply stating the topic of an episode isn't a criticism of it.

[Zero-V]

...People sure have low as **** standards for entertainment. Seriously, an episode about erections. Come on people. Worst. Episode. Ever.
Let us know when you've actually watched the episode before dissing it

[Mr. Insomnia]

I have seen the episode. That was my review for the episode and the members strange praise for the boob tube penis humor.

[Spongebrain2.0]

I have seen the episode. That was my review for the episode and the members strange praise for the boob tube penis humor.

Then perhaps you shouldn't be watching South Park...:shrug:

[Zero-V]

I have seen the episode. That was my review for the episode and the members strange praise for the boob tube penis humor.I take it you've never criticised constructivly before have you? Positives? Negatives? Come on good sir

And in any event, you have no right juding every member who liked the episode in here as having crappy standards, you don't know jack (off) about them or what they consider humerous, it's called an opnion and a preference, if it offends or disgusts you, tough.

[Mr. Insomnia]

Then perhaps you shouldn't be watching South Park...:shrug:No no. Don't get me wrong. I don't hate South Park at all, infact last weeks, I believe it was last weeks, Ghost Cartman dealie was in my opinion the best South Park this season. And I'm not saying that everyone's appreciation of this episode is idiotic, I'm just saying that out of all the episodes this season they had to make the poorest claim as to this being the best. I guess telling it like it is isn't allowed here.

[Fone Bone]

...Did anybody get a big laugh at how Butters uses the urinal?'Loo loo loo, I've got some apples!" I like how he pulls his pants all the way down and his shirt all the way up.:D

What IS a courtesy flush?

[Spongebrain2.0]

'Loo loo loo, I've got some apples!" I like how he pulls his pants all the way down and his shirt all the way up.:D

What IS a courtesy flush?
Courtesy flush is flushing it so it doesn't smell bad for the people in the bathroom. I thought this was hilarious. You know SP was good when you hear people quoting the previous night's episode in school. This was overall the funniest episode I have seen since 'Woodland Critter', This was classic. Jimmy was excellent, And are they phasing out Timmy or what?:sad:

[Zero-V]

I guess telling it like it is isn't allowed here.
Putting yourself above others is'nt allowed here no, opinion however, is, and it seems you can't deal with that.

[Fone Bone]

Courtesy flush is flushing it so it doesn't smell bad for the people in the bathroom. But, wait, wasn't Cartman still on the toilet? Or is the joke that Cartman never flushes?
Edit: Oh, I get it. You're supposed to do it while you're on the john.

[Frank]

But, wait, wasn't Cartman still on the toilet? Or is the joke that Cartman never flushes?
Edit: Oh, I get it. You're supposed to do it while you're on the john.Uh, doesn't Cartman clog the toilet?

[Beat]

...

That was easily the raunchiest, most depraved episode this season.

It was also the funniest.

[Dante Bunny]

I'm not saying it's the worse, not saying it's the best, but to me it just run in the mill humor that Matt and Trey came up with. I have hear worse than that, when Cartman's mom explain what a "rimjob" is during the SP movie, and one of the SP episodes when the boys trying to start a boy band, Cartman stumble into some porn video when Mr. Macky chain to the wall and his mom force him to "drink into this cup". Believe me, I'm not against sex jokes, but it just not me, and this episode that I have rated is a 3. Also, I remember how Butters figure out what "sex" is after that "Lord of the Rings" incident. :anime:

(more ecchi than hentai) :p

[Spongebrain2.0]

This episode was the best, I don't know why people act like it was the most disgusting thing SP has ever done. Believe me, if you think this is the grossest SP, you obviously haven't watched a lot of it;)